A Mockery of Justice: Caricature and the Dreyfus Affair

Musée des Horreurs and Musée des Patriotes

Authored pseudo-anonymously by an anti-Dreyfusard cartoonist going by the name of Victor Lenepveu, this series of posters was disseminated throughout Paris in reaction to the election of a pro-Dreyfusard cabinet whose leaders granted the innocent captain an official pardon in September 1899. They were printed over the course of one year before being banned by the Ministry of the Interior.

An introduction to the dramatis personae of the Dreyfus Affair from an anti-Dreyfusard perspective, these facsimiles of the original colorful posters adopt the attention-grabbing format of theatrical affiches. In the Musée des Horreurs, the figures of Dreyfus’s supporters are distorted and literally dehumanized, cast as animals in a nightmarish menagerie. By contrast, the Musée des Patriotes glorifies those working to undermine Dreyfus. The anti-Semitic journalist Edmond Drumont is cast as a gentleman, while Paul Déroulède, leader of the anti-Semitic Ligue des Patriotes, bears his chest with chivalric heroism.

Despite their ephemeral nature, the series of 52 prints was often preserved by collectors as a set. The Rubenstein Library owns an entire set; the original posters can be viewed in the reading room or online at http://library.duke.edu/digitalcollections/museedeshorreurs/

“Le Traître,” (The Traitor)

“Le Traître”

(The Traitor)

A military sabre pins a notice of guilt into the body of a hydra which has sprouted the head of Captain Alfred Dreyfus. The multi-headed beast, a symbol of indomitable evil, is just one of the many conventions used by Dreyfus’s anti-Semitic opponents to establish his inherent malevolence.

“Ça Porte toujours bonheur,” (It Always Brings Good Luck)

“Ça Porte toujours bonheur”

(It Always Brings Good Luck)

Alphonse Rothschild’s son and recipient of the Legion of Honor for his bravery in battle, Baron Henri de Rothschild is here depicted as a parasitical fly or cockroach emerging from a latrine, a sign of infestation and surely not a sign of luck. 

“Un Bal à l’Élysée,” (A Ball at the Élysée Palace)

“Un Bal à l’Élysée”

(A Ball at the Élysée Palace)

French President (1899–1906) Émile Loubet, who in 1899 pardoned Dreyfus, here hosts the vindicated captain and his supporters Rabbi Kahn, Emile Picquart, Joseph Reinach and Émile Zola in a conspiratorial dance at the president’s official residence, the Élysée Palace. 

“Le Roi des Porcs,” (King of the Pigs)

“Le Roi des Porcs”

(King of the Pigs)

Dreyfus defender Émile Zola is shown as king of the pigs, a reference to Kosher prohibitions against pork. Lenepveu attempts scatological humor, casting Zola’s “oeuvre” and his defense of Jews as “caca international” (international excrement) sullying the French map. 

“Banquier Brocanteur,” (Junkshop Banker)

“Banquier Brocanteur”

(Junkshop Banker)

Head of the Rothschild Frères Bank and regent of the Banque de France, Alphonse de Rothschild is here depicted as a cephalopod whose eight tentacles are anti-Semitic short-hand for the international stranglehold of Jewish capital.

“Dernière culbute,” (Last Summersault)

“Dernière culbute”

(Last Summersault)

Pierre René Waldeck-Rousseau, Prime Minister of the Republic (1899 – 1902) initiated Dreyfus’s pardon. Because of his initial doubts about the Captain, he is depicted as a flip-flopper, performing “a last summersault.”

“Tirez les Lâches,” (Whip the Cowards)

“Tirez les Lâches”

(Whip the Cowards)

Paul Déroulède, poet, anti-Republican activist, and founder of the nationalist Ligue des Patriotes points to his declaration of July 1899 supporting constitutional reform.

"Édouard Drumont"

“Édouard Drumont”

Editor of the anti-Semitic daily La Libre Parole, and author of a number of highly popular anti-Semitic polemics, including the bestseller La France Juive, published in 1886 and reprinted 200 times over 60 years.

Musée des Horreurs

A Mockery of Justice: Caricature and the Dreyfus Affair

12 December 2012-9 March 2013

Rubenstein Library Hallway Gallery
Perkins Library, Duke University

Gallery is open Monday-Sunday
Hours vary, please check online
http://library.duke.edu/about/hours/

Looking for a previous version of this exhibit? Use the Internet Archive's stored version of the page.