Beyond Supply & Demand: Duke Economics Students Present 100 Years of American Women’s Suffrage

Regional Realities

At the heart of the suffrage movement in the United States were the unique battles fought in each state or region. In the Northeast and mid-Atlantic, where the suffrage movement began, suffragists held conventions, parades, protests, and other public gatherings to establish and define the cause. In the South there was concern about the implications of women’s suffrage for racial political and social dynamics—an issue labeled the “Negro Problem”—as most white pro- and anti-suffragists wanted to maintain “white supremacy.” Midwestern suffragists focused their demand for the vote on civic responsibility, asserting claims to citizenship based on their active contributions to community building in the form of libraries, schools, churches, and other institutions. The items in this section illustrate the different contexts of the suffrage movement within each region.

image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image

 

South and Southeast

Front page of leaflet with typed black text on thin, yellowed paper

Woman Suffrage Leaflet “A Solution of the Southern Question” - Full Leaflet 

Henry B. Blackwell—abolitionist, co-founder of the American Woman Suffrage Association, and the spouse of prominent suffragist Lucy Stone—utilizes the population demographics of the Southern states to argue that if “educated white women” were given the right to vote, their votes would exceed those of “colored” male citizens. Racist and classist arguments for statistical dominance and qualified suffrage were used by white suffragists to promote the cause in the South.

Black and white printed photograph in book of a Black woman sitting at a table with books, wearing a long black dress, handwritten cursive underneath reading "yours sincerely A. J. Cooper"

Frontispiece of A.J. Cooper

“The cause of freedom is not the cause of a race or a sect, a party or a class,--it is the cause of human kind, the very birthright of humanity.”

-Anna Julia Cooper

from A voice from the South

Front cover of worn book in maroon and tan with title and author in gold inlay, partially covered by maroon spine binding

A Voice From the South

Anna Julia Cooper’s A Voice From the South “by a Black Woman of the South,” considered to be one of the first published articulations of black feminism, is a collection of essays and speeches about African American women’s rights, education, and status in the late nineteenth century. Using an intersectional lens, Cooper analyzes African American women’s realities facing racism, sexism, economic oppression, and lack of voting rights. Cooper challenges the approach of white women’s movements of arguing for women’s rights at the expense of others, calling for the rights for all humanity.

Title page of publication with typed black text on stained paper framed by decorative lines

Facts vs Fallacies: Anti-Suffrage Allegations Refuted: A Reply to Miss Molly Elliot Seawell

Adele Clark, a prominent artist and founding-member of the Equal Suffrage League of Virginia, worked hard to empower women in Virginia and across the South in the fight for suffrage. In this pamphlet, Clark responds to anti-suffragist author Miss Molly Elliot Seawell’s Why Women Should Not Vote to demystify common misconceptions about marital status, property rights, and social representation in relation to suffrage.

Black and white photograph of 17 women from Equal Suffrage League of Richmond, Va. in front of Washington Monument, Capitol Square, Richmond, holding votes for women banners

Members of the Equal Suffrage League of Richmond, Virginia

West and Midwest

Front page of leaflet with typed black text on thin, yellowed paper

Woman Suffrage Leaflet: "How Women Voted in Colorado" - Full Leaflet

In this leaflet, Hon. James S. Clarkson describes with enthusiasm and even reverance how Colorado women from every social rank “cast a majority of the votes” on election day and “bore their part in the party and public duties of the day” in the first election after women’s suffrage was enacted by state referendum in 1893. Colorado’s success indicated increasing support for women’s suffrage and paved the way for nation-wide women’s suffrage in 1920.

Blurry black and white photograph of a Black woman not looking at the camera, wearing a large bow at her colllar

"Mrs. Naomi Anderson. Lecturer, Poetess, Advocate of Woman Suffrage, Member of the W.C.T.U. [Woman's Christian Temperance Union], President Orphans' Home."

"And, gentlemen, I warn you no longer to stand out in refusing the right for which we contend; in trying to withhold from these noble ladies here and their darker sisters the franchise they now demand. Miss Anthony and Mrs. Stanton, with their high moral and intellectual power, have shaken the states of New England, and the shock is felt here to-day. The echo come back from St. Louis and all through the west; a sensation is aroused in England; and soon the whole world will be awakened to a sense of the value and importance of our cause."

-Naomi Anderson

from "A Colored Woman’s Voice". The Revolution, 4 March 1869, p. 139. 

Suffragist, temperance leader, and writer Naomi Bowman Talbert Anderson was born into one of the two African American families in Michigan City, Indiana in 1843. She began speaking about women's suffrage at the Woman's Rights Convention in Chicago in 1869 then continued on a lecturing tour through southern Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio. Anderson wrote articles on suffrage, Christianity, and temperance that were published in newspapers from the Midwest to California and worked alongside white suffragists to campaign for one of the nation's first state woman suffrage referendums in California in the 1890s. Activists Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton both praised her contributions to the movement, but did not name her when they published an excerpt from her speech in The Revolution, instead titled the piece “A Colored Woman’s Voice”

Full spread cartoon of a map of the United States with the western states in white, while the rest of the map is filled in black with women reaching up to a woman carrying a torch and wearing a yellow cape that says "votes for women"

"The Awakening" from Puck, restored image by Henry Mayer

Northeast

Title page of publication with typed black text on stained paper framed by decorative lines

Proceedings of the Woman's Rights Conventions, held at Seneca Falls & Rochester, N.Y., July & August, 1848

This volume includes a Report of the Woman's Rights Convention held at Seneca Falls, N.Y., July 19-20, 1848, in Rochester, New York, the first of its kind held in the United States. Attracting widespread attention, it was soon followed by other women's rights conventions, including the Rochester Women's Rights Convention in Rochester, New York, two weeks later. Proceedings of that event are also included.

Three maps of the United States in black ink on yellowed paper, showing the progress of suffrage passing in each state

Seein' is Believin' - Have a look! Broadside